These are dark times but I will continue to tell the stories you need to hear in a clear (and usually profane) voice. If I entertain/anger/inform you, preferably all three, please consider becoming a supporting subscriber today for only $5 a month or just $50 a year (a 17% discount!).
Ben Cohen over at The Banter wrote a piece about “The F-Word” aka “fascism,” and why it is 100% appropriate to call Trump and his wider movement fascists. The reason he dived into this “controversial” topic is that, for some reason, it’s actually still controversial to apply the proper label to a movement that is openly fascist and quite happy about it.
Here’s what Ben pointed out:
Robert O. Paxton is widely regarded as the pre-eminent historian of fascism in the English-speaking world. In his book The Anatomy of Fascism in 2004, he defined the ideology in the following terms:
Fascism is a form of political behavior marked by obsessive preoccupation with community decline, humiliation, or victimhood and by compensatory cults of unity, energy, and purity, in which a mass-based party of committed nationalist militants, working in uneasy but effective collaboration with traditional elites, abandons democratic liberties and pursues with redemptive violence and without ethical or legal restraints goals of internal cleansing and external expansion.
This was written over twenty years ago, long before the Trump era in American politics. But Paxton is describing Trumpism to a tee.
You can quibble about whether or not these people are Nazis, but, as I’ve pointed out recently, that won’t be the case much longer. The Nazis are going to take over the party. Soon.
But for now, quibble away. What you cannot quibble about is whether or not they are, in fact, fascists. The Trump regime fits the definition so closely, it’s practically a textbook example.
So why ARE we fighting over this?
Well, to be clear, “we” aren’t. We on the left have been very clear for quite some time that the American right has been moving in this direction for over half a century. Now that they’re exactly where we said they were going, two things are happening:
The centuries-long project of protecting racist white men from consequences is working overtime.
The decades-long project of the legacy press shitting on the left is having a temper tantrum.
I’ve talked about the centuries-long project a number of times. This is America’s refusal to hold racist white men accountable for the evil they do.
We should have hanged the treasonous “government” of the Confederacy. Instead, we let them go home.
We should have hunted down and killed the entire KKK for the murderous terrorists they were. Instead, we left the South and allowed them to enact a reign of terror for generations.
We should have shot every American found to be working for the Nazi Party. We were willing to put over 100,000 innocent Japanese-Americans in concentration camps, but racist white men working to destroy America? Well…that’s a different story.
The steps of the Capitol should have been red with the blood of violent terrorists on January 6th. Instead, they were allowed to go home, too.
America does not like to hold racist white men accountable for what they do. It’s unseemly. It’s unfair. It’s “un-American.” Accountability is for Those People and the left.
Of course, and I’ve written about this a whole lot as well, those days are over. The right has gone too far to play the “We have to look forward, not back, for the good of the country” card this time. 2029 is going to be a very bad year for the fascists and their collaborators.
Now, the second thing we’re seeing here is the legacy press protecting itself from having to admit something: We on the left were right all along. The Professional Left Podcast talks about this allllll the time. The legacy press has spent decades telling us that we were fucking idiots. Alarmists. Absolutely hysterical. You stupid libs and your “sky is falling” nonsense!
I’ve only been writing about politics for 15 years, and I saw the White Christian Nationalism coming a mile away. Did I have some special insight? Am I smarter than the extremely well-paid Jake Tapper and Chuck fucking Todd and insufferable Chris Cillizza? No.1 I am, however, not deeply invested in saving face by denying what has been right in front of me for my entire career writing about politics like they are.
For the legacy press to admit that, well, yes, the left was right all along, they would have to admit that they, the legacy press, were wrong.
These are the smarmy shits that helped the Bush regime lie us into the Iraq War. Have they apologized for that yet? No.
These are the miserable assholes that savaged Hillary and pushed Trump into the White House. Have they even admitted they were “overzealous,” much less lying through their fucking teeth? No.
These are the same fucksticks who hated Biden because he was booooring and attacked him over the dumbest stuff imaginable while pretending his age was the Greatest Scandal In American History and then immediately forgot that the age and health of the president were important when Trump limped into office and instantly started to die in front of us. Have they apologized for ushering in the age of American Fascism? No.
Of course, they haven’t. The legacy press does not apologize. They rankle at the idea of being held accountable. They speak truth to power, you see. How the fuck DARE you speak truth to them! You’re nothing but a fucking peasant and they’re the mighty legacy press!
So, yeah, that’s why they’re fighting tooth and nail against naming and shaming the American right. Partly because they would rather eat glass than admit we were right all along. But also, once they do admit we were right, they would have to start discussing the source of America’s deep divide and severe dysfunction: The Modern Republican Party and its base of brain-rotted bigots.
More than anything else, this is verboten. We can savage women. We can savage the LGBTQ+ community. We can savage Blacks, Latinos, Muslims, Jews, the mentally ill, the handicapped, literally any and all groups are open for criticism. But not racist white men indulging their inner fascist, the way teen girls go through an emo phase. They are swaddled in the protective cloth of eternal innocence and victimhood.
But someday soon, that protection will disappear, and the enablers will disappear with it. That’s when real change will come to America, and we will all be the better for it. Even the racist white fascists who will finally be forced to grow the fuck up.
The Opinionated Ogre is 100% reader-supported. Please help me continue to inform/amuse/outrage you by becoming a supporting subscriber today for only $5 a month or just $50 a year (a 17% discount!)! If not, it’s all good. Welcome to the Ogre Nation anyway!
OK, yes. Obviously, I’m smarter than those assholes. But that’s not the point. 😁











