Especially when it comes to shit details, tasks or missions that have no purpose other than polishing the brass of the senior commanders and the egos of the politicians who give the orders. Iraq was such a shit detail, maybe the biggest in our nation’s history, certainly in competition with Afghanistan and before that, with Vietnam for that dubious honor. George W. Bush launched us into the war with Iraq in 2003 on a thin veneer of lies, that Saddam Hussein had weapons of mass destruction and that Iraq had somehow had something or another to do with the 2001 terrorist attack on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon.
Almost as soon as the United States Army beat Saddam’s military and occupied Baghdad, it became clear to the soldiers on the ground that this was another shit detail. As looting and chaos in the streets of Iraq’s capital city surrounded them, soldiers were given nothing to do. They stood by and watched and set up defensive perimeters, the largest of which soon became known as the Green Zone, and were witness to the bewildered response of those senior to them, the chief culprit being Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld. Here he was, the guy in charge of the Pentagon and all the nation’s military services, and in charge of the war itself, and all Rumsfeld could come up with when confronted by the fact that there was no plan, none whatsoever, for our military to carry out once they had “taken” Iraq, was to utter this gem explaining why we had saved Iraq from Saddam: “Stuff happens. And it’s untidy. And freedom is untidy. And free people are free to make mistakes and commit crimes and do bad things.” He would later compound his crimes against command with his remark, “You go to war with the army you have, not the army you might want or wish to have at a later time,” in answer to a question by the press about why soldiers were driving around in Humvees with canvas sides and tops and frequently no doors, when they were facing attacks daily from roadside bombs planted by insurgents that were killing dozens of soldiers.
Vehicles with better defenses would be developed and deployed later, but they didn’t make the bodies of dead soldiers from the days of Humvees with no armor earlier in the war any less dead. Altogether, by the time the last of our soldiers flew out of Iraq today, 4,400 would die and 32,000 would be wounded, many with debilitating wounds such as lost limbs and brain damage due to blast waves from nearby explosions.
More than 1.5 million soldiers served in the Iraq war during its initial phase from 2003 to 2011 when it was called “Operation Iraqi Freedom,” as if pasting an important-sounding title on the unfolding disaster of our presence there would turn the whole thing into the “victory” it never became. Soldiers knew we had no business being in Iraq right from the start. Even a general who turned into what passed for one of the war’s few heroes, General David Petraeus, was quoted by a reporter in the first days of the war saying, “Tell me how this ends,” a despairing remark that soon became famous as the war ground on and on and on.
Soldiers, including generals, were assigned to Iraq over and over. Petraeus earned a third star and then a fourth as he took over larger and larger chunks of the army’s shit detail in Iraq. Other officers went from being captains to colonels during the war. Sergeants earned stripe after stripe. And still the bodies piled up.
For what? In November of 2003, with the war only six months old, I asked a colonel who commanded a brigade under Petraeus in the 101st Airborne Division in Mosul what the hell we were doing in Iraq. He took a deep breath and said, “Everybody knows the orders we get come from General Rove,” sarcastically referring to President Bush’s political majordomo who was known to be already positioning Bush for reelection in 2004.
That is what the war in Iraq became: an escalator nobody could get off. They couldn’t even come up with a way to prove that we were achieving a “victory.” They couldn’t use the enemy body-count, the figure that was supposed to reflect the victory in Vietnam that was always just one search and destroy mission or carpet bombing away.
So why were we in Iraq, anyway? Well, it morphed from stopping Saddam from “developing weapons of mass destruction” that never existed, to ending the “insurgency” they finally admitted existed, to fighting ISIS, which moved into northern Iraq and took over large swaths of land that the U.S. once thought it controlled. Then there was the threat of attacks from Syrian forces to the West and Iranian-controlled militias from the East. Most recently, Iran has had its proxies hitting U.S. base camps in Iraq with drones and missiles, so the Trump administration started closing our base camps and deploying the troops from Iraq to bases in Jordan, further away from Iran and its proxy militias so that no more American soldiers would die in Trump’s war on Iran that is turning into Bush II, or Iraq II, or a war for oil, or whatever the hell is going on over there.
And now, according to the Pentagon, the last of our military forces have left whatever mission they had in Iraq, marking “a transition from a wartime coalition mission to an Iraqi-led security effort,” according to Hegseth’s hand-puppet, Sean Parnell, the Pentagon spokesman Trump and Hegseth have put up for promotion to Secretary of the Army. Hegseth fired the last one, Daniel Driscoll, apparently because he wasn’t on board with Pete’s testosterone push and was more interested in modernizing the army to fight with drones the way every other military in the world is rushing to do right now.
It never stops. We go into a country like Vietnam, or more recently, Iraq, and we spend years fighting people who don’t want us there, so they are killing us, and we are killing them. And then somebody at the Pentagon comes up with “Vietnamization,” which was turning the fighting over to our Vietnamese “allies,” or a doofus like Parnell calls it a “transition” to mask the fact that one day we were there, with our base camps and the trillions of dollars spent on “security” and weapons and killing Iraqis, and the next day, we’re gone. Like, poof.
No explanation that even attempts to make sense of the last 23 years and the more than 4,000 of our troops who died. No statement that we “won,” because of course we didn’t, and if Hegseth and Parnell claimed that, you’d be able to hear the laughter over the roar of one of Musk’s Starships taking off on its next satellite run.
Soldiers always know. They’re the ones with the muddy boots and the exhausted faces and the sore bones from sleeping on the ground and riding in armored vehicles that never, ever, end up with enough armor to protect them from the roadside bombs and these days, drones and missiles, that wound and kill them.
I remember one day when I was in Iraq in 2003 on a base out near Tal Afar, an outlaw town near the border with Syria. I was sitting in the dining facility having breakfast with a bunch of soldiers who had just returned from another useless mission down in Sinjar, where they were supposed to suppress insurgents who were taking over the town. The soldiers were dirty and tired and hungry. They hadn’t eaten a hot meal in three weeks. Their M-16 rifles leaned against their chairs as they bent over their meal trays inhaling their third servings of eggs and bacon and cut-up fruit and pancakes.
On a flatscreen television that was mounted on the wall of the huge tent-like structure of the dining facility, a man was giving a speech in Washington D.C. to a group of people. The words at the bottom of the screen said the speech was at a conservative think tank called the American Enterprise Institute. The man was wearing a suit. Everyone in the auditorium was wearing suits. The man giving the speech was talking about Iraq and how we were “expanding our footprint” in the Middle East, and our victory over insurgents who opposed us was a sure thing because the United States of America had “the most powerful military in the world,” and “no one can beat us.”
One of the soldiers sitting next to me asked if I knew who the speaker was. I recognized him. It was Douglas Feith. The soldier asked, “who the hell is that?” I answered that he was one of the architects of the war in Iraq.
Suddenly every soldier at the table began throwing pieces of toast and empty half-pint milk containers and plastic forks and spoons at the screen, shouting “shut your mouth you stupid fuck” and similar epithets.
It occurred to me this afternoon as I read Sean Parnell’s remarks about the end of our military involvement in Iraq that men in suits are still telling the same lies to the same rooms full of people wearing suits in Washington D.C., as soldiers get on C-130 transports wearing dirty battle fatigues and dusty boots and fly to new base camps in other Middle East countries to do the same thing we’ve been doing for over twenty years.
The shit details just keep on coming. The presidents keep starting the wars. The generals keep getting promoted. It never ends.




