The Opinionated Ogre is a Stay-at-Home parent first, foul-mouthed hater of fascist Republicans second. He’s been making the most horrible people in the country miserable for 15 years and the hate he feels for American Nazis is eternal and without limits. He plans to stop torturing right-wing trash the day the last fascist dies. So, you know, never. Please help support this potty-mouthed newsletter for just $5/month or $50/year (Almost 17% less!)
Sometimes, the legacy press makes me weep tears of absolute despair. Even when acknowledging the horrid racism of the American right, they just cannot stop themselves from expending tremendous effort to whitewash it.
Here’s an article from last week in The Atlantic about how the death of St. Charlie the Bloodless has “unleashed” antisemitism on the right:
You can love Yair Rosenberg, or you can hate him. You can cry bloody tears about Zionism or point out that he’s punched neo-Nazis in the nose for years. Whatever your feelings, that’s for you. Me? I’m looking at this rose-tinted view of Republican politics with a massive amount of aggravation:
Before his life was ended by an assassin’s bullet, Charlie Kirk was trying to save the conservative coalition from turning on itself. To liberals, the late activist was known for debating left-wing students on college campuses. But on the right, Kirk was waging another battle, against people on his own side.
For years, Kirk was dogged by the overtly racist followers of the young white-nationalist influencer Nick Fuentes. An avowed admirer of Adolf Hitler, Fuentes sought to subordinate racial, religious, and sexual minorities to white Christians.
…
Kirk recognized that this crude conspiracism was poisonous to his project of popularizing the conservative cause.
Rosenberg is being extremely generous to Kirk here. OK, that’s a lie. Oh, not me. Rosenberg. He’s lying. Sorry, not sorry. Charlie Kirk was a Christian Nationalist. More specifically, he was a White Christian Nationalist. A point Rosenberg goes to great lengths to gloss over.
He aspired to forge a broad conservative coalition that could outlive Trump and bridge the traditional Reaganite GOP with the rising new right. As Kyle Spencer, the author of Raising Them Right, a book about Turning Point’s ascent, put it: “Charlie Kirk arrived on the scene as a kid who just graduated from high school in 2012, saying, ‘I have a vision. It is possible. This party is stodgy. It’s outdated, it’s old white men. We need to attract young people, Black people, Latinos.’” In 2024, when Kirk quarterbacked the Trump campaign’s ground game, it looked like he had finally pulled that off: The former president made major gains among nonwhite and low-propensity voters, and he finally won the popular vote.
This ignores who Kirk actually was, which is convenient for Kirk. But it’s bullshit. Kirk was not just a Christian with political ambition. He was a Christian who believed America should be run explicitly based on a specific vision of biblical fascism. The “Seven Mountain Mandate” calls for theocrats to seize absolute control, or “dominion,” of family, religion, education, media, arts and entertainment, business, and government. Kirk said this out loud. If I know this, Rosenberg knows this.
If you’re not familiar with this movement, also called “Christian Dominionism,” I strongly urge you to read up on it because it is the basis for Project 2025. It is an explicitly white nationalist movement. There is no room for you if you are not white. It is explicitly misogynistic. Women are to be subjugated. It is explicitly anti-LGBTQ. They consider any deviation from heterosexuality to be a sin punishable by death. Finally, all other religions are heretical. The Bible does not call for tolerating heretics and living in peace with them. It calls for their death.
That would include Jews. If I know this, Rosenberg knows this. So why he feels the need to lie about it, I cannot say. But Charlie Kirk was not subtle about his Christian Nationalism.
Did you know the Opinionated Ogre has a weekly podcast? It’s true! New episodes every Thursday! Catch the latest episode here:
Now, it’s true that Kirk defended Israel and pushed back on open antisemitism. But the why matters. It wasn’t because of his love for humanity or innate decency. Charlie Kirk was a racist piece of shit. He hated Jews just as much as he hated Blacks and Asians and Latinos and and and. We were not his brothers. We were, as all Christian Nationalists see us, useful idiots.
It’s important to understand that the eschatological1 prophecies of the Evangelicals require the existence of an Israel populated by Jews. If all the Jews left Israel2 and it became a Muslim-only country, that wouldn’t work. It has to be Jews in Israel for the End Times to come, and all the “good” Christians to be saved by Jesus, blablabla. What happens to all the Jews? They convert or die and spend eternity in hell.
This is the vision of Christianity Charlie Kirk pimped to his audience. We Jews were never anything more than disposable pawns, destined for genocide. Christian Nationalists hate us. They’ve always hated us, and when they have the power to do so, they will “deport” us to Israel whether we want to go or not, so their beloved prophecy can come true. And when it doesn’t, they’ll probably drop a bunch of nukes on us in frustration. After all, when Christ doesn’t return, who are they going to blame except the Jews?
Charlie Kirk was not saving the right from antisemitism. He was keeping it hidden. Buried out of sight so we would still play along with the charade.
Here’s the thing, though: The right’s lurch to antisemitism did not start after Kirk died. These motherfuckers right here? They were marching back in August of 2017:
They were chanting “Jews will not replace us!” while Charlie Kirk was still quite alive and breathing.
Trump’s 2016 campaign was so explicitly racist and so explicitly appealed to white nationalism, I stopped speaking to my Trump-voting in-laws because I knew, I fucking knew!, that antisemitism was going to spread like a fucking cancer.
My wife, who is not Jewish, did not understand, but I told her, “They always get to the Jews.” Surprise! Two months after Trump was elected, Richard Spencer, the most famous neo-Nazi in America at the time, moved ten minutes away from where we lived so he could be closer to Washington DC and the center of power he thought he would now have access to.3 Several months after that, Nazis were marching in Charlottesville and murdering Heather Heyer.
This was eight long years before Charlie Kirk was killed. The right’s descent into white nationalism has been accelerating the entire time. If I know this, Rosenberg knows this.
Long before Kirk was shot, Greg Bovino was running around the United States dressed like a Nazi. Stephen Miller and Kristi Noem turned ICE into an explicitly white nationalist organization using Nazi propaganda.
If I know this, Rosenberg knows this. He went to fucking Harvard. Don’t tell me I’m smarter and more insightful than a goddamn Harvard graduate. I’d like to think I’m a clever little ogre, but not that clever. I do not have a crystal ball that lets me predict the future behavior of the American right.
What I do have is an unwillingness to lie about it. I have no need to sanitize who and what these people are, which, apparently, Rosenberg does. I was very clear about this back in November of last year. The Nazis are going to win the war to take over the right. They were always going to win:
As I explained, it doesn’t have to be this way, but the American right has never once turned towards the center after a loss. Every defeat has been met with calls for doubling down on extremism. This is the history of the American right from the Civil War until today. If I know this, Rosenberg knows this.
Now the GOP is an openly fascist party of white nationalists. There’s nowhere left to go but to Nazism, the end stage of their ideology. This process started long before Charlie Kirk was born, it was happening while he rose to prominence, and it didn’t accelerate after his death. It’s just continuing down the path it was already on.
The Trump regime burst out of the gate the second time with a fully-formed whiter nationalist agenda ready to go. Stephen Miller’s Gestapo has been rampaging across the country, inciting violence and recruiting the worst of the worst. The regime has been openly appealing to Nazis, knowing that they are losing the minority vote. This is a calculated move that was happening even before Charlie Kirk was assassinated. This is who they are. This is who they’ve always been.
Charlie Kirk wasn’t defending Jews from a goddamn thing. He wasn’t a good person with noble intent, trying to hold back the tide of hate on the right. He was a fucking monster hiding his true face until he ascended the throne. Then he would have gleefully ripped away the mask and celebrated the antisemitism he and his fellow white Christian Nationalists wallow in every minute of every day.
To suggest otherwise is to look at the last year/decade/60 years and ignore what we all saw happening. That may suit Rosenberg’s narrative, but that is not the truth, and I’m sick and fucking tired of people pretending otherwise.
I write to help you cope with the fear and anger threatening to overwhelm you every day. If this newsletter gets you through these dark times, please consider becoming a contributing supporter for only $5 a month or just $50 a year (a 17% discount!). Thank you for everything!
There are only 266 days until the midterms, and the regime is panicking. They’re afraid of us. Keep making them afraid every single day. Remember, you are never alone. We beat the fascists once. We will fucking do it again.
Hooray! I finally got to use this word in an article! I’m a serious writer now!
Maybe they decided to move to China. We Jews love Chinese food.
That didn’t work out for Spencer. Turns out, he was ahead of the curve by several years. If he had waited until now, he would be in prime position to be America’s Top Nazi.














