All you really need to know about Pete Hegseth is that his rank when he left his service in the Army National Guard was Major. The rank of Major is the worst rank in the officer corps. It’s between two ranks eligible for commands – Captains can serve as company commanders, and Lieutenant Colonels can command battalions. Not every officer who achieves the ranks of Captain and Lieutenant Colonel is awarded a command, but the possibility, and thus the ambition, is there.
Majors serve on the staff of a brigade or a division. They don’t get to give orders. Nobody serves under their command. They are in between in every bad sense of that status. Nearly every Major I encountered – including my own father, who was a Major for a very uncomfortable number of years – exuded stifled ambition from every pore. They want to be Lieutenant Colonels so badly, they can taste it, and yet, it is considered untoward to let one’s ambition show too much. A Major depends on the ratings given to him by his commander, so the urge to suck up is almost irresistible. But Majors are hated for being suck-ups, so they can’t even really get away with the one thing they think can get them ahead.
It’s the classic “damned if you do, damned if you don’t” rank, and Majors hate it almost as much as other soldiers, in ranks both above and below, hate them.
Hegseth’s order to the generals and flag officers in all the services to come to Quantico to listen to his lecture on fitness and haircuts and the evils of DEI was the resentment of a Major come fully to fruition. It explains the grim, studiedly unresponsive looks on the faces of the generals. To them, the man giving the lecture wasn’t Secretary of Defense -- or God help us, War – it was Major Hegseth.
So, here is how he’s getting his revenge. The Washington Post reported today that Hegseth is ready to execute “some of the most significant changes at the military’s highest ranks in decades.” The Post reports that Hegseth’s plans will “slash the number of four-star generals in the military,” which when he took office he had announced would be one of his goals.
This is not the way you run the Department of Defense. As the top civilian running the military establishment of the country, you want the generals on your side. We’ve already seen the photographs from Quantico. They’re not on his side. So, Hegseth has apparently said, well, fuck you. I’ll show you who’s boss.
There are so many things wrong with that attitude, it’s hard to know where to begin. You don’t have to be the generals’ friend – in fact, you don’t want to be – but you need their respect and loyalty. At the same time Hegseth is trying to force the Navy to order Senator Mark Kelly back to active duty to court martial him, he’s telling the people who run the Navy, Army, Air Force, Marines, and Coast Guard that he’s going to cut their ranks and reduce their influence over how their services are run.
That is precisely the way Majors behave, and every general and flag officer in uniform knows it.
Hegseth’s plan to reorganize the military involves changing the command structure, cutting the number of service headquarters commands, known in mil-speak as “combatant commands” from 11 to 8. The new structure would deemphasize U.S. support of Europe, the Middle East, and Africa and concentrate the Pentagon’s focus on the Western Hemisphere, in accordance with the insanely racist and ignorant national security strategy document that was released last week.
Hegseth has already fired or forced into retirement more than 20 senior general officers. At his strutting, egomaniacal speech to the generals at Quantico, Hegseth went all “my way or the highway,” telling them that if they don’t like the way he and Trump do things, they should “do the honorable thing and resign.” These men and women get up every morning and think about their service to the country. They’re not paid very much, but the amount of responsibility on their shoulders dwarfs what the oligarchs and techno-bros carry. They can’t use money and raises to motivate those who serve under them. They must depend on the sense of honor and service of those under their commands to carry out orders that can, and do, involve life and death.
Hegseth is treating the military as if it’s a business. His plans to reorganize the Department of Defense resemble the way companies acquire and merge with each other. Every time there is a corporate consolidation, people lose jobs, especially those at the top of the corporation that is being taken over. Hegseth plans to combine the current U.S. Southern Command, the European Command, and the Africa Command into one central “International Command.” The commands of the Western Hemisphere – Northern and Southern Commands – will be consolidated into a single “Americas Command.”
It all sounds like a move to make things more efficient, but it’s really Hegseth consolidating and centralizing his control by cutting down the number of generals who report to him, so he can more closely control what they do. By reducing the number of top jobs, he will also make the contest to see who gets a senior command more cutthroat among the generals. Unhappy generals who are fewer in number are more easy to frighten and control than happy generals.
What Hegseth is ignoring is the strength derived in military units by familiarity of top commanders with those under them. It’s harder to know the strengths and weaknesses of 50 commanders under you than it is to know how well 25 are running their commands. Hegseth doesn’t care about how well things are being run. He just cares if he’s the one who is in overall charge. He has ordered senior officers in the Pentagon to undergo lie detector tests as a way of catching leakers and scaring military officers into pledging loyalty to him.
This is, naturally, insane. Officers and enlisted soldiers in the military take seriously their oaths to uphold and defend the Constitution. Their loyalty isn’t to an individual. It is to the supreme law of the land and to the nation they serve.
Soldiers have a way of dealing with people like Hegseth who think they can invade their world and change the way they do business. They cut them out. Hegseth thinks he can better control the generals if there are fewer of them. He’s going to find that fewer generals means there will be fewer people who are choosing not to report what is really going on down in the ranks they command.
What Hegseth doesn’t know will hurt him. He’s not going to like it when his phone rings one day, and it’s Trump complaining that someone told him something that Hegseth doesn’t know anything about. What’s going on? Why did that happen? Why didn’t you tell me this was coming?
Major Hegseth won’t have the answers because one or more of his generals didn’t bother to inform him. It won’t be death by a thousand cuts. A few deadly stabs in the back will do. The generals didn’t smile when he delivered right-wing applause lines at Quantico. They won’t be smiling when they slip the knife in, either.





