This is going to be one of those “Things That Are Going To Happen” articles that no one will believe. I’m writing it anyway because when it does happen next year, or maybe a few years later (but I’m betting on it really getting started soon), I’m going to point to this article as proof I saw it coming a mile away. I will not be happy I was right. I’m rarely happy I am right about this crap.
Let’s get to it. I have been screaming, for YEARS, that the Republican Party is going to go full Nazi. That was ignored, too. But now, here we are, with the GOP infested with goosestepping Hitlerjugend and getting worse by the day. There is no stopping this cancer. Within a handful of elections, the GOP will be openly proud to be running under the banner of Nazism, and the legacy press will be working 24/7 to normalize this aberration.
What I am writing about today is the flip side of that coin. Sort of. Here’s my prediction that no one will believe:
As the Republican Party is consumed by Nazis, there will be an explosion of “Communism” on the left.
But unlike the very real Nazi cancer on the right, the left’s “Communism Problem” will be fake. All of it.
Oh, there will be useful idiots on the ground who rush out to get sickles and hammers tattooed on their arms. There are already some of them now. But what we’re going to see, I promise you, will be a large, coordinated, and suspiciously well-funded group of “professional” communists. Talking heads with massive social media followings (definitely not bots gaming the algorithm!) that will spring up overnight. Established “far left” influencers who were all-in on socialism “suddenly” discovering that socialism is stupid. So played out and uncool and, I swear to god, “centrist!” Communism is actually the path forward!
The reason for this magical surge in love for communism is not that complicated. It all comes back to the necessity of the “both sides” lie.
Substack has been slowly choking off traffic to smaller newsletters like this for more than a year. If you appreciate the stories I tell and the voice I tell them in, please become a contributing subscriber and push back on corporate censorship. We need all of the independent media we can get before the only news we’re allowed to consume is what is allowed by a fascist regime controlled by billionaires. For just $5 a month or just $50 a year (a 17% discount!), you can help fight back against Substack’s censorship. Thank you for reading and keeping this newsletter going.
If subscriptions aren’t your thing, you can leave a one-time PayPal or Venmo tip instead!
I’ve written about this before. The GOP going full Nazi (as well as pro-pedophilia) presents an insurmountable problem to the political discourse in America. The foundation of our politics is that we pretend both parties are the same. No matter what Republicans do, we pretend they are normal. No matter how extreme and violent and corrupt they get, it’s all washed away with “Democrats are just as bad.”
That dynamic cannot survive the GOP’s transition to a party of literal Nazis. It is understood by everyone that Nazis are genocidal monsters. There is no credible way to whitewash them. The New York fucking Times tried it back in 2017, and the public outrage reduced them to a fine mist. A Nazi GOP kills the both-sides lie.
But without the lie, the shield that has protected Republicans for decades disappears. The public would see them for who they really are: A party of ravening monsters. Liars. Grifters. Thieves. Fascists. Rapists. Pedophiles. Genocidal animals.
A true public accounting of the Republican Party would mean the END of the Republican Party. That cannot be allowed.
But what to do? There is no way to equate Democratic Socialism with Nazism. To call advocating for universal health care and school lunches and taxing the rich as extreme as advocating for the mass murder of all non-white, non-Christians in the United States is a non-starter. Even the most bug-eyed conspiracy nutjob can’t square that circle. I thought this would be the end of it. Nazism would finally kill the “both sides” lie and, with it, the Republican Party. It hadn’t occurred to me that there was a way out: Astroturf Communism.
Communism has a long and proven track record of killing tens of millions of people. Communism really is dangerous, not because the ideology itself is inherently genocidal, but because it has repeatedly led to genocidal outcomes. Like capitalism, communism is great on paper. In practice, it relies on implementation by people. This wouldn’t be a problem except people are greedy, stupid, arrogant, and corrupt. Without checks on their power, they, more often than not, run amok, and the results are millions of fatalities. We justify the piles of dead bodies under capitalism because a handful of people get extremely wealthy, but, really, neither system left unchecked works out very well in the long run for the average person living under it.
So, in order to protect the “both sides” lie, the solution to the GOP’s Nazi problem is obviously to manufacture a “Communist Revolution” on the left.
Republicans have been trying to fabricate one for months. Years, really. Every whisper of socialism on the left is conflated with communism. They rely on the public’s general ignorance of the difference between the two. We’re a very stupid nation sometimes. Not for nothing, Medicare is socialism. Social Security is socialism. The word is right fucking there in the name. Municipal services like the police, the fire department, sanitation, public schools. These are all examples of socialism. We all pay for them. We all collectively benefit from them. No one person owns or operates or profits from them.
But while this screeching used to work, it doesn’t anymore. Republicans spent decades crying “socialism!” in order to terrorize their voters. And not at all coincidentally, there appeared a large, coordinated, and suspiciously well-funded group of “professional” socialists. The professional “far left” loved socialism and made lots of noise and got lots of attention. I’m sure this wasn’t a ratfucking operation at all. Totally organic and just happened to gain ground just when the Republican Party tilted over to extremism.
A funny thing happened, though: Socialism, specifically Democratic Socialism, became quite popular. Especially among younger voters. The same voters who are increasingly dominating elections.
Democratic Socialism turned out to have a pretty good track record. It is, after all, what most of Europe follows. Whoops. Maybe the ratfuckers should have picked something less functional. Too late now.
I know, tinfoil hat shit, right? Totally crazy! Except, you know, if you pay attention to the DSA, you’ll notice there are two types of members. The first group can explain Democratic Socialism. How it works, why it’s good, what we would fix, and who would benefit. They have specific, concrete policies they want to implement and plans to do it. These are serious people.
Then there’s the other group. They have…slogans. They’re not really sure what Democratic Socialism is, but they hate the system and both parties! Burn it all down! Policy is boring. Revolution is exciting! These are not serious people.
The first group is going to dominate the conversation going forward because people want solutions, not slogans and mindless anger. The second group?
They’re going to become “communists.” They will be the useful idiots led by the “professional” communists who, again, will have suspiciously large platforms and be suspiciously well-funded.
This “Communist Revolution” will not represent the Democratic Party. It will not represent the left at all. It will be a manufactured astroturf movement. But just like that, the legacy press will have the flipside to the GOP’s Nazi problem.
There will not be a single elected “communist” in the entire Democratic Party. There will not be a single mainstream “communist.” They will not represent the left in any significant way. They will be a fringe movement, but they will be given an astonishing amount of attention from the press.
The Opinionated Ogre needs you to smash that subscribe button like it’s Donald Trump’s face! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support this work!
Subscribe now
Comrade Chris and Comrade Tina will make the rounds on all the major networks, explaining how they’re the “real” left wing of America. How they’re going to bring communism to the nation and overthrow the corrupt corporate something-something blablabla. Workers Unite! No private property! Down with capitalism!
Just like that, the GOP isn’t extreme anymore. Sure, they’re Nazis, but have you seen how crazy the left is?! Because when both sides are extreme and dangerous, no one is.
I know this all seems far-fetched. Who would ever fall for something this ludicrous? I dunno…the same people who listened to the ratfuckers in 2016 and then again in 2024? When they told us not to vote for Hillary because she murdered Vince Foster and she was a warmonger, while Donald Trump would never EVER abuse his power? That the Supreme Court wasn’t important? That Kamala was a cop and Trump was a “populist?” That Biden was too old, but Trump wasn’t?
The professional “far left” is out there right now trying to whitewash Tucker Carlson, a literal white nationalist, because that’s the current play. If they’re told to push communism by their paymasters, they’re going to start spouting Karl Marx and waxing on and on about the wonders of collectivism. They have no ideology beyond “whatever keeps Republicans in power.”
The legacy press, of course, will eat it up with a spoon, grateful that they won’t have to talk about the violent extremism of the right. They’ll know it’s all bullshit. It won’t matter. A fake communist revolution will give them the fig leaf to continue the “both sides” lie indefinitely.
For my part, I would love to be wrong. I would love nothing more than to wake up one year, two years, five years from now and see the “both sides” lie reduced to cinders. I would love to see Republican extremism finally reach a breaking point where it can no longer be hidden and ignored. But too many people have too much invested in protecting the GOP from itself. When they start seig heiling at their rallies, something will have to be done. That something will be to invent an equal and opposite threat from the left, and Zohran Mamdani filling potholes and planting trees isn’t going to fucking work. Democratic Socialism doesn’t pack the boogeyman punch they need. It’s too popular and, worse, too functional to be a counterweight to Nazism.
My guess is that the Communist Revolution is coming. And it’s going to be 100% bullshit. Watch for it. Know who your enemies are and act accordingly.
I write to help you cope with the fear and anger threatening to overwhelm you every day. If this newsletter gets you through these dark times, please consider becoming a contributing supporter for only $5 a month or just $50 a year (a 17% discount!). Thank you for everything!
Not a fan of long-term subscriptions? That’s OK! I’ll be your one-night stand with a one-time donation through PayPal or Venmo! I’m easy like that! Just don’t tell Mrs. Ogre! 😜